Skip to content

Category Archives: Book reviews: Politics

Mythology in the making

12-May-08

CEO PresidentLee Myung Bak: Korea’s CEO President
Seoul Selection, 2008

SterneSterneSterneSterneSterne

When their country has pulled itself up from the devastation of war in the space of fifty years, and a man has risen from poverty to the highest office in the same period, Koreans have every right to feel proud of themselves and their country. That said, Seoul Selection’s pamphlet profiling Korea’s new president is, for this reader at least, a bizarre publication. Part manifesto, part hagiography, the text is anonymous apart from some glowing clips from newspaper editorials. The only credit is given to Robert Koehler, who compiled the material.

The first part of this oddity is a brief biography, of more interest to historiographers than historians. Lee’s birth is accompanied by the conventional auspicious dream visiting his pregnant mother – in Lee’s case, his mother dreams that the moon had climbed up under her skirt. We then follow Lee through the grinding poverty of his early childhood, his 18-hour days at Hyundai, and his single-handed defeat of a gang of thugs hell-bent on looting the corporate safe. Lee’s rags-to-riches story of course personifies the success of South Korea since the 1960s. Every detail of the account may be entirely true, but the tale is told in a firmly Plutarchian style, with lots of homely details. All we are lacking is a comet appearing in the sky at Lee’s birth, a convenient she-wolf to act as wet nurse and a few vipers to give the young toddler some wrestling practice, and we would have a full-fledged classical hero.

If the brief biography somehow fails to connect with this particular reader, at least the brief account of Lee’s achievements as Seoul’s Mayor provides some interesting detail for those who know Lee as the creator of the Chonggyecheon: improvements to the transport system, and the creation of Seoul Forest and Seoul Plaza are recounted. But the account of his achievements is again told in a partisan style, emphasising how he persisted in his views against the scepticism of those around him. It’s as if the section was written by President Lee’s marketing department.

After a selection of newspaper editorials we come to a section setting out Lee’s goals for his presidency. I heard recently that a Korean journalist had counted as many as ninety-two pledges that Lee made during the election campaign. I couldn’t identify all of them in the description of Lee’s programme as laid out in this pamphlet, but it’s certainly a full agenda.

The booklet is available from Seoul Selection for $7 (though the price on the cover is $12). If it was published entirely at Seoul Selection’s own initiative, it’s an ill-judged decision. If I was an author who had already been published by Seoul Selection, I would feel decidedly miffed that I shared a stable with this particular effort. And if Seoul Selection was leaned on by Lee’s supporters to print it, let’s hope that by conceding this once they have earned so much political capital that they can now publish whatever they like in future without any interference.

So, as an account of why a Korean might be proud of their new president, this book meets the objectives. The problem is, who wants to read a marketing brochure?

Mark Clifford: Troubled Tiger

05-Jul-06

Troubled Tiger.jpg(M.E. Sharpe, 1998)

SterneSterneSterneSterneSterne

Chronicles the modern history of Korea from the 1960s to the mid-90s, focusing on the drive for economic growth and the control exerted by the Blue House over the direction of the economy. Clifford gives us a politically balanced view, emphasising the successes of Park Chung-hee, but not shrinking from laying bare the corruption, coercion and mistakes made by Park, Chun and their successors.

The development of the Chaebols is covered - explaining how they were family feifdoms (and still are?), and how their growth has been geared towards not profits but growth in sales and assets - at almost any cost; and how their growth has been funded less by equity capital investment and more by loans from banks who had to follow government orders.

Also illuminating is Clifford’s description of the methods the Blue House used to keep people in line. Tax audits were one way. Ring any bells?

There are some great stories, told with a journalist’s flair, for example the account of the amateurish attempts to bribe US congressman in the mid-70s – the KCIA-led “Operation White Snow” (which inevitably became known as the “Koreagate” scandal). And the narrative is spiced with detail from personal interviews: a particularly amusing one is the story of Roh Tae-woo’s state visit to Mexico in 1991, where Roh refused to sully himself by associating with grubby Korean businessman – despite the fact that part of the purpose of the visit was to drum up business.

The subtitle of the book is Businessman, Bureaucrats and Generals in South Korea. What I would have liked more of, given that this book was revised in 1998, is a blow-by-blow account of the market turmoil in 1997; I would also have liked a more in-depth examination of the workings of a typical chaebol - the cross-subsidies within the group, the inherent profitability or otherwise of the different divisions. I guess though that that sort of analysis is more appropriate in a business-style book. This book is aimed very much at the general reader, and it is none the worse for that.

Read a fuller review of this book at the Korean Studies portal, which rightly raises a caveat about the liberal, Anglo-American perspective from which the book is written.